15 September 2011

Pin It

Analysis of UPA Ministers Properties Union Ministers richer by 3.3 Crore in 2 years.

Analysis of UPA Ministers Properties Union Ministers richer by 3.3 Crore in 2 years.

Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) disclosed the financial assets and liabilities of Ministers online
Association Democratic Reforms (ADR) and National Election Watch (NEW)
have analyzed the declarations of all the 77 Ministers and also compared it with the assets declared by them during 2009. This report is based on this analysis.


Analysis of assets declaration of Union Council of Ministers in the PMO

1. The average asset value of a minister in the current ministry is Rs. 10,63,55,097 (Rs 10.6 crores). In 2009, the average asset value of a minister was Rs 7.3 Cr.

2. 77% of our Ministers (59 out of 77) are crorepatis based on their declarations to Prime Ministers Office (PMO)

3. The current ministers on an average are Rs 3.3Cr richer than in 2009. This is inspite of the fact that 19 ministers in their 2011 declarations to PMO have not given the value of several of their movable and immovable assets listed in their declarations

4. The highest asset increase in rupees has been for Dr. S. Jagathrakshakan of DMK whose assets show an increase of Rs. 64.5 crores in two years (from 5.9 crores in 2009 to 70 crores 2011). He is followed by Praful Patel with an increase of Rs 42 Crores (from 79.8 crores in 2009 to 122 crores in 2011) and Kamal Nath with an increase of Rs 26 Crores (from 14 crores in 2009 to 41 crores in 2011)

5. According to recent newspaper reports, the net worth of Kamal Nath’s assets has been calculated to 256 crores, which is including the assets of the companies in which he has business interest.

6. The highest asset increase percentage wise has been for Dr. S. Jagathrakshakan (DMK). His assets have grown by 1092%. He is followed by Smt. Panabaka Lakshmi (INC) with a growth of 828% in her assets and Shri Tusharbhai Chaudhary (INC) with a growth of 705% in his assets.

7. The richest Minsters are Praful Patel (assets worth 122 crores), S. agathrakshakan (assets worth 70 crore) and Kamal Nath (assets worth 41 crore

8. 15 ministers have shown a decrease in their assets as compared to the assets they declared in 2009. 6 of them have not given the value of several of their assets.

ASSET INCREASE DETAILS OF MINISTERS FROM THE LOK SABHA

Name - Dr. S. Jagathrakshakan
Party – DMK
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 70 CRORE Plus
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 5 Crore Plus
Asset increase – 64 Crore Plus
Percent Increase in Asset - 1092%

Name - Shri Praful Patel
Party – NCP
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 122 Crore+
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 79 Crore+
Asset increase – 42 Crore+
Percent Increase in Asset – 53%

Name - Shri Kamal Nath
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 41 Crore+
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 14 Crore+
Asset increase – 26 Crore+
Percent Increase in Asset – 189%

Name - Shri Jyotiraditya Madhavrao Scindia
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 32 Crore+
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 14 Crore +
Asset increase – 17 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 119%


Name - Shri Milind Deora
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 33 Crore+
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 17 Crore+
Asset increase – 15 Crore+
Percent Increase in Asset – 89%

Name - Shri M. K. Alagiri
Party – DMK
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 34 Crore+
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 19 Crore+
Asset increase – 15 Crore+
Percent Increase in Asset – 80%

Name - Smt. Panabaka Lakshmi
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 16 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 1 crore +
Asset increase – 14 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 107%

Name - Shri Sushil Kumar Shinde
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 17 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 8 crore plus
Asset increase – 9 crore plus
Percent Increase in Asset – 107%

Name - Shri Kapil Sibal
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 38 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 30 crore +
Asset increase – 7 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 25%

Name - Charan Das Mahant
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 11 Crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 4 crore +
Asset increase – 7 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 179%

Name - K.H. Muniappa
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 10 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 5 crore +
Asset increase – 5 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 102%

Name - Kumari Selja
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 9 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 4 crore +
Asset increase – 4 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 94%

Name - Sharad Pawar
Party – NCP
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 12 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 8 crore +
Asset increase – 3 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 43%

Name - Salman Khursheed
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 6 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 2 crore +
Asset increase – 3 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 139%

Name - V. Kishore Chandra
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 28,29,14,000
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 24,74,10,and 000
Asset increase – 3,55,04,000
Percent Increase in Asset – 14%

Name - Ajay Maken
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 4 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 4 crore +
Asset increase – 50 lacks +
Percent Increase in Asset – 13%

Name - Pranab Mukherjee
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 3 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 2 crore +
Asset increase – 37 lacs +
Percent Increase in Asset – 14%

Name - Rajeev Shukla
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 30 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 7 crore +
Asset increase – 22 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 294%

Name - Ashwani Kumar
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 25 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 8 crore +
Asset increase – 16 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 193%

Name - Smt. Jayanthi Natarajan
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 23 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 7 crore +
Asset increase – 15 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 191%

Name - Smt. Ambika Soni
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 9 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 7 crore +
Asset increase – 1 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 24%

Name - Vilasrao Deshmukh
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 7 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 5 crore +
Asset increase – 1 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 29%

Name - Ghulam Nabi Azad
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 2 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 1 crore +
Asset increase – 1 crore +
Percent Increase in Asset – 100%

Name - Shri Vayalar Ravi
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 1 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 18 lacs+
Asset increase – 93 lacs +
Percent Increase in Asset – 502%

Name - Dr. Manmohan Singh
Party – INC
Assets disclosed in PMO website – 5 crore +
Assets declared during Lok Sabha 2009 elections – 4 crore +
Asset increase – 68 lacs +
Percent Increase in Asset – 16%

I can only say Today in India Indian democracy means laws made by rich class for the benefit of rich by the rich people of India.

Reality views by sm –
Thursday, September 15, 2011

Tags-News Politics UPA Cabinet Ministers Properties Analysis

14 comments:

Renu September 16, 2011  

The list clearly shows where the corruption starts...

Dinesh September 16, 2011  

While India's Growth is 9%, 77% of Corrupt Cabinet Ministers growth is 100% to 1000%. UN should Honor them as INT TERRORISTS. Their growth rate is higher than DAWOOD.

sm,  September 16, 2011  

dinesh,thanks.

Arti September 16, 2011  

The corruption starts from the very top level in our country and goes right to the bottom...

Kirti September 17, 2011  

There are four possibilities with two things. The two things being Assets in 2009 and Assets declared now in PM website.
The four things are:- A is true, B is true. A is false, B is false. A is true, B is false. A is false, B is true.
Mathematics say that there is only 25% probability in what you are charging the ministers with.
Tell me the source of information.

AKS September 17, 2011  

This is an vital information. Very few newspapers have highlighted this info. I am surprised. Is our media scared of publishing such information? where is the free India? How many people read on the net? I think government does spend millions of rupees on advertisement for their benefits, why can't they issue a full page advt announcing this details? I would be more than happy if some one who is of real concern can spend some funds to put this information in all daily local news papers.
Let the CM knows of all this.
SM thanks for the information.

Kirti September 17, 2011  

It seems stupid. The information. Looks like Aa bail mujhe maar.
Information in IT world cannot be trusted. It is important that a committee is made and IT issues are sorted out. It should not be that difficult too in the current scenario of IT.
As a blogger and millions of other IT users, you know what we face. A clean government and an absolute corrupt opposition. It is possible that opposition are controlling websites and changing figures.

AKS September 17, 2011  

I think dear kirti is shocked.. this figures are true. I think kirti can ask a RTI for this information which will authenticate the facts and clear his doubts. This is no hacking we keep track of this information too and if required you can contact ADR www.adrindia.org
The fact is in 2009 the ministers have disclosed under-valued assets and now they feel that by doing so they may end up in more trouble.
The major issue is the affidavit disclosing the assets at the time of nomination for election is not challengable and if wrong info is given there is no legal action against the candidate.. one more point for Election Reforms.

sm,  September 17, 2011  

Aks thanks.
Kirti,thanks.
ADR is an organization which has studied this in depth.
Please read the news papers you will find little bit information.

Kirti September 17, 2011  

Thanks SM.
There is a limit to the allegations as there is limit to a country's border. The allegations are absolutely untrue. The government is for the poor.

Team G Square September 17, 2011  

Superb analysis ! , if the declared asset is swollen by so much percentage , just imagine about the undeclared wealth .

sm,  September 17, 2011  

Kirti,thanks.
Team G thanks.